Spotify and YouTube Music both have a free tier with ads and a paid tier that removes music ads and adds downloads. Spotify Premium offers lossless audio, and some Premium plans include monthly audiobook hours, while YouTube Music lets you upload your own song library and comes bundled inside YouTube Premium.
What each one costs
Spotify lists four Premium plans in the US. These are regular monthly prices before tax, as of November 2026.
- Premium Individual: $12.99 a month for one account.
- Premium Student: $6.99 a month for one verified account.
- Premium Duo: $18.99 a month for two people who live together, each with a separate Premium account.
- Premium Family: $21.99 a month for up to six people who live together, including the plan manager.
On the YouTube side, YouTube Premium includes the YouTube Music Premium benefits, and YouTube's US Premium page lists the individual plan at $15.99 a month. That plan also brings ad-free YouTube viewing, video downloads and background playback on mobile, with some content exceptions. YouTube family plans cover the manager plus up to five more members at the same residential address, and each member uses a separate Google account. YouTube does sell two-person plans, but its published country list does not include the US.
What the free tiers allow
YouTube Music's free tier is ad-supported and lets you play songs, music videos and podcasts on demand, with queuing, repeat and unlimited skips. For catalog music, though, background playback, audio-only playback and downloads are Premium benefits. Most podcasts are an exception and can play in the background or be downloaded without paying.
Spotify Free is also ad-supported. In September 2025, Spotify announced Free updates that let listeners pick and play any song, search for a track and play it, and play a shared track right away. Offline listening is narrower, since Spotify's help page says the free version can only download podcasts.
Sound quality
Spotify Premium on desktop, mobile and tablet goes up to about 320 kbps, plus a Lossless setting of up to 24-bit/44.1 kHz FLAC. Lossless needs Premium, works in qualifying mobile and desktop apps and some third-party devices, and does not apply to music videos, podcasts or audiobooks. Spotify adds that connection type and device compatibility can affect the quality delivered.
YouTube Music's audio quality settings top out at 256 kbps, using AAC and OPUS. Normal, at up to 128 kbps, is the default, so the High setting has to be chosen by hand.
Spotify Free offers about 24, 96 or 160 kbps in the apps. The Spotify web player uses AAC at 128 kbps for Free and 256 kbps for Premium, and its quality cannot be adjusted manually.
Videos, uploads, podcasts and audiobooks
YouTube Music's catalog reaches past studio albums into official music videos, remixes, covers, concert footage and live recordings. It also accepts personal uploads of up to 100,000 songs from a computer, in formats including FLAC, MP3 and M4A. Uploaded songs play ad-free, offline and in the background without a Music Premium subscription, but they stay private and family members cannot play them.
Spotify plays audio files stored on your own device through its Local Files feature, and its US help page lists thousands of music videos as a Premium feature. US Premium Individual includes 15 audiobook listening hours a month, Duo and Family give those hours to the plan manager only, and Premium Student includes none. Unused hours expire each month.
Neither paid plan promises ad-free podcasts. Both companies say podcast ads and host-read promotions can remain for paying members.
Downloads and devices
Spotify Premium allows up to 10,000 downloaded tracks on each of five devices, and you need to go online at least once every 30 days to keep them. YouTube Music Premium downloads likewise stay available for up to 30 days without a connection. Spotify plays on one device at a time per account.
Spotify runs on desktop, mobile, tablet and web, plus selected cars, TVs, game consoles and smartwatches. YouTube Music covers Wear OS watches, compatible Garmin watches, Apple Watch, HomePod, Android Auto and Apple CarPlay. On TVs it works through the main YouTube app, because the dedicated YouTube Music app is not available on living room devices.
Which one fits
If lossless audio or audiobooks matter to you, Spotify Premium has them, since YouTube Music's listed settings stop at 256 kbps and Premium Individual includes 15 audiobook hours a month. If two people share a home, Spotify's Duo plan is an option YouTube does not offer in the US. The full plan breakdown is in Is Spotify Premium Worth It?
If you already own a large music collection, YouTube Music's 100,000-song upload locker plays those files for free. If you also watch a lot of YouTube, note that one YouTube Premium payment covers both ad-free video and Music Premium. Is YouTube Premium Worth It? covers that side.













