IPS vs VA, Which Monitor Panel Should You Pick?

ASUS lists its IPS ProArt PA279CRV at 1,000:1 typical contrast, while BenQ says 3,000:1 and more is common on VA. Dell's enhanced IPS Black UltraSharp U2725QE also lists 3,000:1 native contrast.

Technobezz
IPS vs VA, Which Monitor Panel Should You Pick?PanuShot / Shutterstock.com

Contents

Don't Miss the Good Stuff

Get tech news that matters delivered to your inbox.

IPS and VA are both LCD panel types that rely on a backlight, and a key trade-off between them is color consistency against contrast. Dell says IPS generally keeps color consistent across wide viewing angles, while VA commonly provides strong native contrast. If you edit photos or video, IPS is the type makers aim at that job. If you want stronger contrast, VA is the type makers associate with it, though Dell's enhanced IPS Black monitor publishes the same 3,000:1 figure as its VA model.

How the two panels are built

LG's Australian panel explainer expands IPS as in-plane switching and VA as vertical alignment. It describes VA displays as using vertically aligned crystals that are backlit. Samsung's Australian buying guide describes the liquid crystals in an IPS panel as arranged parallel to the screen.

Contrast

Contrast is where VA leads on paper. BenQ's panel explainer says contrast ratios of 3,000:1 and more are common on VA, and LG's Australian site describes standard IPS contrast as 1,000:1. The figures below are the makers' published specifications, not independent measurements.

  • ASUS ProArt PA279CRV (IPS, 27-inch): 1,000:1 typical contrast. ASUS lists a separate maximum contrast figure of 3,000:1.
  • BenQ PD2730S (IPS, 27-inch 5K): 2,000:1 native contrast.
  • Dell UltraSharp U2725QE (enhanced IPS Black, 27-inch): 3,000:1 native contrast.
  • Dell S3425DW (VA, 34-inch, 1800R curve): 3,000:1 native contrast.
  • ASUS TUF Gaming VG34VQL3A (VA, 34-inch, 1500R curve): 4,000:1 typical contrast.

The Dell pair shows why the panel label alone is not enough. Its enhanced IPS Black UltraSharp and its curved VA monitor publish the same 3,000:1 native figure, so check the contrast line on the specification page for the model you are considering.

Viewing angles and color

Samsung's Australian guide describes VA viewing angles as moderately good and slightly inferior to IPS and OLED. The specification sheets do not show that difference. The IPS-based ASUS PA279CRV and the VA-based ASUS VG34VQL3A both list 178 degrees horizontally and vertically, measured at a contrast ratio of 10 or more.

On color, ASUS associates IPS with color reproduction and wide viewing angles. It says the PA279CRV was designed for professional video editors, and it also names colorists, designers and photographers as intended users. That monitor lists 99% Adobe RGB, 99% DCI-P3 and a Delta E below 2. Dell's U2725QE lists 99% DCI-P3 and an average Delta E below 1.5, while its VA-based S3425DW lists 99% sRGB and 95% DCI-P3.

Response time and motion

Samsung's Australian guide says IPS response times can be as fast as 1 ms, which is a statement about what the technology can do and not a specification for every IPS monitor. The same guide says VA may show ghosting in fast-moving scenes unless it is well optimized. ASUS says its Fast IPS technology switches liquid crystal elements up to four times faster than conventional IPS for a 1 ms gray-to-gray response time, with availability that varies by model.

Published numbers on gaming VA monitors are also low. The ASUS VG34VQL3A lists a 1 ms gray-to-gray response with a 180 Hz maximum refresh rate. Dell's S3425DW lists 1 ms in Extreme mode, 3 ms in Fast mode and 5 ms otherwise. The IPS monitors aimed at color work are slower on paper, at 5 ms for the ASUS PA279CRV and the BenQ PD2730S.

Which one fits

If you do color work, look at IPS, because the IPS models here publish Delta E figures and ASUS aims its IPS-based PA279CRV at editors, designers and photographers. For that kind of screen, see the best monitors for photo editing, and this guide covers calibrating a monitor in Windows.

If you mostly watch or play dark content and want a curved screen, look at VA, because the curved models here are VA and publish 3,000:1 to 4,000:1 contrast. The best curved gaming monitors list is a place to start. If fast motion is the priority, compare the response time and refresh rate on each model's specification page, since both panel types list 1 ms on gaming models and Samsung flags ghosting as a risk on VA that is not well optimized.

Share